I do not really understand the "Mechwarrior might be released for consoles"-hate. If I'm not totally wrong, MW2 was also a console title and it worked.
Yes, I have seen Mechassault and I know that it has not much in common with what we perceive as "Mechwarrior"-Franchise. But judging from the scarce evidence there is (a tiny trailer, tiny posts on a blog..) I think the conclusion that MW:3015 would be a sequel to Mechassault is somewhat premature.
On a sidenote: after I had played my first couple of matches MWLL, seen the 3015 trailer, and played the Mektek-MW4-Re-release, I kept wondering for a while how a 'true' Mechwarrior with all its depth could be realised on a console. I am convinced that this is possible. I took a look at the PS3-Controller and from my point of view, it is easily possible to map all the functions you needed for MW4 and MWLL -- including tactical stuff like radar and communication, chainfire / groupfire, coolant... -- onto the PS3-Gamepad. You'd have to put some of the less frequently used functions (like re-grouping weapons, giving orders, shut-down...) into radial menus, but if it is done well, there should be no usability issues (compared to PC controls). However, in that scenario I assume that the developer puts some thought into the pad configuration (1. player has to be able to use as much combat-functions while dogfighting 2. mapping should be consistent with mental models 3. make radial menus well readable and with a low chance for pushing wrong buttons 4. group functions in a way that makes sense... )
Also, the typical problems that gamepads have with first person shooters won't apply to mechs, as even light mechs move much more sluggishly than a first-person-shooter-persona.
So no, I don't see why a mech-release on a console would be bad
per se (other than 'it has gone wrong before', which is no valid reason imo) and thus there is no reason to whine before even the slightest bit of information has been released.
Just wait and give it a shot, if it is ever released at all. You can still whine when it is actually bad and then continue to play MWLL.
